- Romancing the Stoned
- Posts
- Turn the Cheat Around
Turn the Cheat Around
This hated not-a-trope is much maligned
Hi, subscribers, Domscribers, and nonsubscribers,
I’ll keep this intro brief because the ramble is so long. Sorry-not-sorry for the Gloria Estefan earworm. I couldn’t think of a title for this newsletter. Instead, I had this song on a loop in my head. So, now it’s in yours too.
Real-life infidelity sucks. There’s nothing fun about it, except maybe the naked part for the people engaging in it. But I love reading romance novels that address it. That’s not exactly a popular stance, and so I’ve collected some thoughts about it below.
Turn the Cheat Around
It doesn’t matter if it’s cheating on or cheating with, a good portion of romance authors and avid romance readers draw the line at the “cheating trope.” DNF. DNR. “Absolutely the fuck not.” You see the complaints over and over on social media—which is probably why I have a pathological need to periodically yell “It’s not a trope!” So, let’s get that part out of the way first. Cheating by itself is a plot point. An event. A thing that happens that moves the book along. Is a death a trope? No. Is a car accident a trope? No.
What makes cheating tropey is how and why it occurs. The how and why is also what makes it a good or a bad story. But too many people focus on the broad strokes. (Not just the naked kind.) If a character even looks at, or breathes near, a person besides their love interest, it’s somehow considered cheating. No one else is allowed to exist in their heart or impact their pants. It’s an absolutist, strict-monogamy outlook that doesn’t allow for nuance—when so many stories excel at those nuances! It makes them richer and more interesting. It allows for so much deep, emotional exploration.
Historical romances, for example, have had cheating plotlines for years with few reader complaints. It’s extremely common for a viscount or a duke to still have a mistress while falling for his love interest—who is often on the marriage mart and girded by class and gender-based restrictions. The belief that you’re not supposed to have fun sex with your wife, only with women of dubious character, is still extremely prevalent today. The body count discourse? Come on now. So, one of the central themes in a lot of historicals is the characters realizing that passion does belong in a marriage—the earl embracing commitment is in tandem with the wallflower blooming sexually. And then they find their own way in that restrictive social sphere and time period. People who don’t read the subgenre assume that it’s all antifeminist, reinforcing the patriarchy and class divides, etc. But very frequently, the pairs end up doing their own eccentric thing, bucking convention with their equally eccentric friends who get spin-off books. (Which, incidentally, is also what happens in a lot of queer historical romances and what happened in queer historical reality. To paraphrase renowned chaos theorist Dr. Ian Malcolm, love finds a way.)
![]() | In Sherry Thomas’s Ravishing the Heiress, Fitz is still fixated on the woman he was courting before he was forced to marry Millie for her dowry and fill the family coffers. It’s a name-only but very amiable marriage, and Fitz and Millie team up to run her father’s tinned food company. But when his ex turns up widowed and willing, it feels like a second chance. That cheating bastard, right? No. Fitz is a doofus whose arc is realizing that he grew past that youthful infatuation and has loved Millie all along. Quietly competent Millie is way ahead of him, managing him and his life, biding her time. Because it’s eight years into their marriage—the point they agreed upon to finally consummate it and have a baby. |
“He ought to be thinking of Isabelle’s ardent declaration of love. Of the past, the future, anything but the present. But tonight, after the carriages left, there would be Millie, her scent like a breeze from their lavender field at the height of summer, her skin as smooth as the finest velvet.
Their eyes met. She flushed. Desire tumbled through him.”
These close friends and partners in business have to navigate this new, awkward, sexually-charged dynamic. And Fitz is technically cheating on both women! Making love to his wife while feeling increasingly (and chastely!) uncomfortable with the women he thought he belonged with. It’s layered, painful, and glorious to read.
Having an heir is also the impetus for another cheating-laced beloved historical, Waking Up With the Duke, by Lorraine Heath. It kicks off with one of the best first lines in the genre: “I’ll consider your debt paid in full if you get my wife with child.” Uttered by the Marquess of Walfort to his cousin Ainsley, the titular duke. Walfort is a paraplegic due to a horrific carriage accident three years before. His wife Jayne has always blamed Ainsley for their wild carousing that night. She hates this man. But Walfort needs a son to inherit his title, and she does really want a baby. | ![]() |
What ensues is a riveting angstfest of Ainsley awakening Jayne’s desires, Jayne realizing what her husband has denied her (he doesn’t kiss or hold her, all their pre-accident sex was perfunctory) and Ainsley struggling with giving up his own child and the woman he’s always pined for. It all culminates in a shattering reveal. Since it’s romance, we know how it works out. Infidelity is the set-up, happily ever after is the pay-off.
Another favorite of mine, A Gentleman Undone, by Cecilia Grant, turns the still-has-a-mistress concept on its head. Lydia thinks of herself as a common sex worker, not someone so fancy as to be a courtesan, and sees no shame in it. She’s infinitely pragmatic. She has a protector for at least half the book, and she skims off the top of his gambling winnings to ensure her future security. When she fleeces war veteran Will, he’s intrigued and wants in on the card-sharp action—but she’s still getting action from Edward.
![]() | She’s a genius with numbers and odds. She’s not giving up a sure bet quite yet. And you know what? Fair. Not only is Will lacking funds of his own, but he comes from a respectable family. He has siblings who move about in society. Association with her could ruin their reputation. Lydia knows that better than he does. Of course she needs back-up plans for when he goes back to where he belongs! It’s complex and exquisitely written—and if you guessed that where Will belongs is with Lydia, you’d be correct. If she’d been unattached and bedded him immediately, the build to that hard-won eventuality wouldn’t hit the same. |
Okay, Suleikha, those are historicals with social conventions that mitigate the cheating. What about contemporary romance? What if a perfectly content wife walks in on her handsome, rich husband being ridden on the couch by some hussy wearing nothing but high heels? Oh, you mean like in Silent Flames by Cate C. Wells? Marriage-in-trouble stories have long been a staple of romance novels. And, often, the trouble in question involves infidelity. But it’s not as simple as moving past cheating and gaining forgiveness to get to the HEA. It’s also about emotional maturity and building to a believable rapprochement. It’s not supposed to be easy. The angst and struggle of it all is the point. With Wells’s Adrian and Cora, the reader is allowed to see the full breakdown of this relationship that seemed fine on the surface. Cora loses her shit spectacularly and justifiably—making Adrian realize that his wife is as broken as he is. It all works out because every screwed-up pot has a dysfunctional lid.

Humans are messy and flawed. So why can’t fictional characters be messy and flawed in this particular way too? It’s true of both fiction and reality that people often partner up without really knowing each other. Which is why compelling fallout from cheating often involves characters seeing the truth of each other and also the truth in themselves. Adrian and Cora made surface assumptions about one another and never looked deeper. Infidelity is a catalyst that forces characters to open up to each other, to be vulnerable and honest in ways that they weren’t before. We talk a lot about how romance novels are a safe place, how they’re wish fulfillment. It’s the reassurance that no matter what goes wrong, everything will be okay. In real life, most of the unfaithful don’t deserve forgiveness, and there’s more tears than resolution. In books, we get to do it differently. We get pages and pages to work through it all. Romance authors give us the catharsis of facing the cheating head-on and then the balm of the HEA.
“Don’t like, don’t read” is always valid. No one who hates cheating as a plot element has to go out and try books outside their comfort zone. I’m not going to strap anyone to a chair A Clockwork Orange-style and force Waking Up With the Duke upon their eyeballs. But stripping the complexity of well-written infidelity arcs down to a blanket “trope,” and dismissing them all outright, means missing out on a lot of outstanding stories.
Thank you for reading! If you enjoyed yourself, please consider hitting subscribe, checking out some of my books, or dropping a tip in my Ko-fi below.
-Suleikha



